A Revolutionary New Blockout Technique
for Etching Metal
by Katharine Wood with Paul Silverman
Photo Credits: Paul Silverman
from Volume 15, Number 3, August 1996
Discuss
this article in the Glass on Metal Forums

One of the great
satisfactions of etching is that whatever you can draw, you can
etch. However, if you have an elaborate design, the
application of the resist can take many hours. But now, the
etching process will be radically changed by a technique developed
by Paul Silverman, which I have further refined for enameling.
A photographer by
profession, Paul began experimenting with etching in an attempt to
simplify the photo-etching process. Realizing that printed
circuits had to be etched with total accuracy, he utilized this
technology and has come up with an incredible new method of
blockout for champleve and basse taille enameling.
In recent years, much
has been made of Xeroxed images and their direct transfer to
metal. This method was initially intriguing and still
performs well for a light surface etch. However, its
limitations become distinctly obvious when a deeper etch is
required. Small lines do not hold up; larger areas develop
pinholes. With this new technique, the finest lines can be
quickly applied and then etched with complete accuracy for many
hours, resulting in a clean, deep etch. Paul has generously
supplied all his notes for this article. As an artist and
teacher of enamel, I have tested his findings and expanded on them
with my own work and in the classroom.
The first step is the
same age-old step that precedes all enameling - clean the
metal! It is especially important with this technique to
clean very well. Unfortunately, there will always be some
who will not succeed simply because they have not taken the time
to clean well enough so that the water 'sheets' on the
metal. Cleaning consists of scrubbing with Scotch-Brite or
similar abrasive sponge and cleanser (with chlorine). Rinse
well, and finish off by cleaning the metal with alcohol.
Hold the piece carefully by the edges. Wear surgical rubber
gloves (available in any hardware store) to hold the piece, so
that no finger grease is transferred accidentally onto the edges -
and, don't forget to clean near the edges of the metal. If
there is a 'lip' or 'burr' at the edge of the metal shape, which
may occur from machine cutting, it must be filed off before
cleaning. This is very important, as the metal must be
completely flat, with no warpage or areas even minutely
raised. The reason for this will be obvious later.
However, leave the burrs on the back of the piece; this will stop
the metal from sliding during transferal.
In the meantime, you
should have a sheet of PnP blue paper already Xeroxed with the
images you want to transfer. This PnP blue paper is a fairly
new invention used to transfer printed circuitry to metal.
It is available from Thompson Enamel. It comes with full
instructions on how to use, but a little clarification is in
order.
First of all, select
the image you want to etch. It can be your own design or it
can be a copyright-free design from, for example, a Dover design
book. The important thing is that the image must be high
contrast, i.e. black and white.
In theory, no
half-tones or shading - although one might consider experimenting
at some point and seeing what happens. Also, no color
images. Remember, in etching you are simply dealing with
positive (the raised unetched copper) and negative (the
etched-away areas). Therefore, you need a pure black and
white image - although it can be as detailed as you like.
Note that this technique works best if the surrounding area of the
image is black; the more area transferred, the better the
adhesion.
Next, run your image
through a Xerox machine onto the PnP blue paper (onto the 'dull'
side). Be warned - some copiers cannot handle this thick,
acetate-like paper. Be especially wary of older machines
with rollers inside; they can jam. Use the newer direct feed
machines that do not overheat. The key here is to
experiment. I have had success on a number of
machines. Be sure your Xeroxed image is dark; you
might want to press 'darker' on the machine. Just be sure
there are no smudges on the printed image. Also, it saves
time and money to cut and paste several designs onto one sheet of
paper (black construction paper works best). Xerox the whole
collection at one time onto the PnP blue, thereby filling up the
sheet. The different designs subsequently can be cut out and
used when needed, and there is little waste. One
warning: everything comes out reversed when transferring, so
take this into account, especially with lettering.
So, now you have a
very clean, flat piece of metal and a sheet of PnP blue paper
filled with designs. Choose the image you want to
transfer. To center or register image, outline your metal
shape on the PnP blue artwork and cut out neatly. Cut the
transfer slightly smaller than the metal (otherwise the image
might lift off the metal), but leave one edge flush with metal
edge. Make pin holes in the PnP transfer sheet to line up
with punch marks in the metal. Next, still wearing your
surgical gloves, place the metal onto a piece of wood. You
can tape it on from the back so it doesn't move around during the
next step. Get out the iron. Yes, the one used for
clothes! Set the temperature on 'high' and wait until it is
heated up. Give the metal one last swipe with alcohol, as
copper oxidizes quickly. The dull side of the PnP paper
should be face down making contact with the metal. Start
ironing outwards at the edges of the paper first, rotating the
piece on the wood until the edges are tacked down. Continue
over the rest of the piece. Keep the iron constantly moving
in a circular motion. Watch for wrinkling and bubbling of
the PnP paper and iron down promptly, turning down the temperature
setting a little. Do this for five minutes; larger pieces
may take longer. Again, experiment! Ironing should be
smooth; light pressure is all that is needed. The design
should start showing black through the PnP sheet. When this
occurs, continue until design shows completely in black, and then
stop ironing. Let the piece cool totally, it will be very
hot. Then, starting at an edge, peel the PnP sheet slowly
and carefully off the metal. The iron can be cleaned, when
cool, with a swipe of acetone.
What you should now
have is a completely accurate and (almost) perfectly transferred
image in black (this acts as a resist) on your copper. And
it only took about five or ten minutes! I say 'almost
perfectly transferred image' because sometimes there will be areas
that need a little touching up. Sometimes a fine line is
broken in one spot, or a large area needs extra protection.
In these cases, simply take traditional resist (asphaltum, for
example) and touch up or cover those areas.
Can you over or under
iron? Yes, to both of these, but there are simple
remedies. If you have under ironed (too little time or too
low temperature), the transferred image will show up blue instead
of black. If it is really under heated, the image will not
transfer at all. If you do not remove the PnP paper, but
simply lift a corner and peek, you can lay it down again without
moving the image (keeping perfect registration) and keep ironing
till the image shows black. Actually, I have etched some
pieces with the 'underdone' blue resist, and it still holds up
pretty well.
If you over iron (too
hot or too long), you will have areas of blue showing within small
sections of the transferred black design. In other words,
fine lines will 'block up'. In this case, simply take a
scribe or pin and gently scratch off these parts.
Finally, cover the
back of your piece with contact paper. Trim the edges.
Graphing tape (available at art supply stores) in different widths
is good for borders - both for the original drawing and the metal
piece. Edges as well as borders also can be covered with
electrical tape folded over the back. Or you can paint by
hand a curved or irregular border with resist (don't forget resist
on the edges).
You are now ready to
etch! I use ferric chloride on copper; it can be used on
nickel silver and brass, but the ironing takes somewhat longer,
and these metals are not good for enameling. Nitric acid is
no good for this method. If you want a design in fine
or sterling silver, you must either have the copper original cast
(sterling) or roller-print it onto the silver (fine), using very
thin copper as your master.

As always, the piece
must be placed face down to etch in the ferric chloride. I
put it on top of a thicker version of Scotch-Brite, saturated with
mordant, in the solution. If you have a regular, thick
enough border, you can use self-stick plastic furniture protectors
('cushion feet') for support. From this point, all the
regular rules for etching apply (see my article in Glass on Metal,
Oct. 1990). After etching, enamel can be applied.
The only limitation
for this technique is that you cannot 'double etch' with it, since
the receiving metal must be flat. If you want a double, or
multiple, etch, this must be done in the traditional way, with
hand and brush and regular resist. A whole sheet of metal
can be patterned and then cut out into jewelry shapes or cut and
sculpted. It does not even have to be enameled, but can be
used for many jewelry applications with a textural background.
Enjoy this wonderful
new technique; it will open a world of possibilities to the
imaginative enamelist and metalsmith.
Discuss
this article in the Glass on Metal Forums
|